Gustau Alegret: “Trump Has Discovered the Limits of Trumpism: Permanent Confrontation Is No Longer Enough”

Gustau Alegret
Marc Amat
By Marc Amat  | November 17, 2026

Catalan international journalist and political analyst based in Washington.

The US midterm elections have shaken the American political landscape. Two years after Donald Trump’s return to the White House, Democrats have regained control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate, securing victories in traditionally Republican territories. The outcome opens a new chapter of political confrontation in Washington and raises questions about the strength of the electoral coalition that brought Trump back to the presidency in 2024.

A few weeks ago, we spoke with Victòria Alsina about the key factors behind the US midterm elections, the influence of Trumpism, and the particularities of the Republican electorate. Now it is time to analyze what happened at the polls and what consequences these results may have. To do so, we spoke with Gustau Alegret, a journalist and political analyst based in Washington with more than 25 years of experience in international affairs. Throughout his career, he has worked for media outlets such as NTN24, CNN en Español, TVE, TV3, and RAC1.

What is the main conclusion we can draw from these elections?

That American democracy has exercised its corrective power in response to a presidency that has generated significant opposition because of its policies and its highly personalized style of leadership, far removed from what the presidential office has traditionally represented in the United States. I believe this election was essentially a referendum on Donald Trump. He deliberately personalized the campaign and asked his supporters to vote as if his own name were on the ballot. The result should therefore be interpreted as a very clear rejection of his presidency.

How has this result been received in the United States?

With three different emotions: relief, joy, and surprise. Relief among those who were concerned about the direction of presidential power; joy among Democratic voters; and surprise among many Trump supporters, especially those linked to the MAGA movement, who did not expect a result of this magnitude. Trump remains President and the leader of the Republican Party, but these elections have shown that his ability to mobilize voters has limits.

What explains this rejection? How decisive was the economy?

Gustau AlegretIt was fundamental. Republicans tried to mobilize voters through immigration, culture wars, and ideological confrontation, but citizens prioritized other concerns: inflation, gasoline prices, housing costs, and the challenges of making ends meet. It is a situation that people in Catalonia can easily understand. Trump’s tariff policies have increased the cost of living, compounded by the impact of the war with Iran on energy prices.

Rising diesel costs affect the transportation of goods, while higher fertilizer prices particularly harm farmers, many of whom are Republican voters. Ultimately, all of this translates into higher costs for families.

One of the most significant changes occurred among younger voters. What happened?

The United States is a deeply aspirational country. When young people complete their studies, they want to enter the workforce, advance professionally, and build their lives. But when wages fail to keep pace with prices and access to housing becomes increasingly difficult, that sense of future opportunity disappears. In a favorable economic environment, young people may prioritize ideological or identity-related issues. When the economy does not work for them, however, they tend to hold the president responsible. Many chose either a protest vote or to support alternative policies in the hope of regaining optimism about the future.

There has also been a shift in Latino support toward the Democrats. Is the coalition that gave Trump victory in 2024 beginning to fracture?

Clearly. Groups that played a decisive role in his victory are changing their voting behavior. We see it among Latino voters, but also among young people, lower- and middle-income workers, and even in traditionally Republican rural areas. The mobilization of African American voters was also significant. Texas is a particularly striking example. In some areas where Trump had won by double-digit margins in 2024, Democrats have now achieved landslide victories. The coalition that seemed so solid two years ago is beginning to crack, and that should worry the Republican Party.

Where does Donald Trump stand after this defeat?

He is in a very weak position, but it would be a mistake to write him off. Presidential power in the United States is enormous, and Trump will continue to wield it until the final day of his term. He has already warned that he will use the veto power to block congressional initiatives. Democrats do not hold the two-thirds majorities needed to override presidential vetoes without Republican support. Therefore, much will depend on whether some Republican lawmakers decide to distance themselves from the president. There are already voices within the party warning that, unless they change course, 2028 could be extremely challenging.

And what about the Democratic Party? Can it see this victory as an endorsement of its political project?

Gustau AlegretIt would be making a serious mistake if it did. Democrats achieved an important electoral victory, but they must now transform it into a political project capable of attracting citizens. A significant part of the support they received was borrowed support: independents, moderate Republicans, and voters who wanted to punish Trump but do not necessarily identify with the Democratic Party. In addition, the party faces significant internal divisions between its democratic socialist wing and more centrist factions. They will have to find common ground and build a shared message. Trump will undoubtedly try to exploit those differences.

Do you think Trump will change course or double down on his current policies?

Everything suggests he will choose the latter. After an electoral defeat, a president can engage in self-criticism and try to win back independent voters or conclude that he simply did not go far enough and intensify his approach. Trump appears to be choosing the second path. The replacement of Susie Wiles as White House Chief of Staff and the appointment of a much more ideological figure point in that direction. For that reason, I believe we are heading into two years of intense political confrontation.

In Europe, Trump and his supporters are often viewed through certain stereotypes. Do we need a better understanding of American society?

I believe so. We cannot reduce Donald Trump to a madman, nor can we treat the more than seventy million Americans who voted for him as if they were. That kind of simplification prevents us from understanding the phenomenon. Trump uses polarization as a political tool because he has found it effective in gaining power. We can question his policies, but we also need to explain why such a large segment of the population placed its trust in him. A deeper and more nuanced analysis of American society is needed, and that is not always reflected in European interpretations.

What can we expect during the two years leading up to the 2028 presidential election?

A great deal of confrontation. Democrats will have to restore Congress’s oversight role over the executive branch, while also demonstrating that they can advance proposals that improve people’s lives. If, two years from now, inflation remains high, gasoline prices have not fallen, and families see no improvement in their circumstances, they will have failed to meet the expectations they have generated. There is, however, a hopeful element: faced with political disillusionment, many citizens chose to vote rather than abstain. That demonstrates that they still believe in the capacity of democratic institutions to bring about change.

Could this new balance of power also reshape US foreign policy?

Gustau AlegretWithout a doubt, because Congress has significant powers in both budgeting and foreign policy. In the case of Iran, an agreement that reopened the Strait of Hormuz could help reduce energy prices, although the effects would not be immediate. As for Israel, criticism of unconditional support for Benjamin Netanyahu’s policies is growing, both among sectors of the Democratic left and within parts of the MAGA movement, albeit for different reasons. Regarding Ukraine, Congress could approve new aid packages or additional sanctions against Russia. All of this could result in constitutional conflicts between the legislative branch and the White House.

Finally, what have these elections taught us about the United States?

Three things. First, Trump has discovered the limits of Trumpism: identity-based mobilization, permanent confrontation, and highly personalized leadership are not enough when citizens feel their economic situation is worsening. Second, American democracy has activated its system of checks and balances, and Congress will regain influence in relation to the presidency. And third, Democrats may have won the election, but they have not yet won the future. They successfully channeled a powerful anti-Trump vote, but they must now prove they can offer a credible political alternative.

Enquire here

Give us a call or fill in the form below and we'll contact you. We endeavor to answer all inquiries within 24 hours on business days.